Why Does AI Keep Writing the Same Story? Three Explanations
Why does AI keep writing the same story? Training, user demand, model collapse; pastiche and prosthetic memory; a scene showing emotion without naming it.
Why AI Stories Sound Alike: Training, Demand and Model Collapse
Summary and Conceptual Framework
Work from the last two years points the same way: stories written by language models resemble one another more than stories written by people do. This article sets three explanations side by side. The first concerns training: the stages that turn a model into a helpful assistant flatten the rise and fall of narrative. The second concerns demand: a small but very productive share of users asks for familiar patterns again and again. The third is a risk: if model outputs seep into the training data of later models, the rare disappears first. The problem also has older names. Jameson's pastiche, Landsberg's prosthetic memory and Fisher's ghosts are concepts devised for mass culture before AI. This article proposes no new term. The one question Objective Projection adds is this: is the sameness only in the plot, or also in how emotion reaches the reader?
AI writing the same story over and over means that the stories language models produce resemble one another more than stories by human writers do; research links this to training stages, to user demand and to the risk of a model feeding on its own output. Anyone who has asked an AI for a story notices it at some point: the prompt changes, but the skeleton of the story stays familiar. The hero learns a secret, loses something, and at the end looks out of a window with a small hope. That impression has now become a measured finding. The question of this article is not the finding itself but its cause.
Is the sameness an impression or a finding?
Thennal DK and Hans Ole Hatzel compared stories written by people in the r/WritingPrompts community with stories produced by ten language models from the same prompts. Similarity was measured both by human evaluators and by three different automatic methods. The result pointed the same way under every method: the models' stories are more similar to each other than human stories are to each other. According to the authors, the most advanced models converge on a "mean" narrative that comes close to individual human stories but lacks the collective diversity of human writers. Telling the model what not to write (negative prompting) or raising the temperature did not meaningfully reduce this similarity.
The StoryScope study by Jenna Russell and colleagues approaches the same question through narrative choices. Each of 10,272 prompts was answered by one person and five language models. With stylistic cues set aside and only narrative features used (such as a character's choices and how time is built), human and AI stories were separated with 93.2% macro-F1; separating the six authors from one another, the figure was 68.4%. Macro-F1 is an average measure of success across classes; it is not the same thing as accuracy. The model stories gathered in a shared region of narrative space, while the human stories were more spread out.
The experiment by Anil Doshi and Oliver Hauser, published in Science Advances in 2024, looks at the question from another side. Some participants took ideas from a language model before writing a story. Stories by those who took ideas were judged individually more creative and better written; but these stories were more similar to each other than stories written by people alone. The authors compare the situation to a social dilemma: each individual gains, while the collective space of new work narrows.
A finding in the same direction also comes from outside English. At EMNLP 2026, Yuanchi Ma and colleagues studied stories generated by models in Chinese web literature, extending Propp's narrative functions to 34 functions. According to their abstract, the model stories reuse similar sequences of events and predictable endings; the authors attribute this uniformity mainly to models failing to grasp what the narrative functions mean and falling back on rigid generation patterns.
Interpretation: Read together, these studies show that sameness does not stay only in the text a model writes on its own; it can pass into the text of the person who takes ideas from the model. This suggests that the problem is not only a problem of "AI text".
Three explanations
The similarity has no single cause. The three explanations below do not exclude each other; they can work at the same time.
| Explanation | What it found | Source | What it does not say |
|---|---|---|---|
| Training | Post-training stages reduced variation in theme, emotion and linguistic diversity | Li et al. 2026 | It rests on a single model family |
| Demand | More than a third of conversations involve fiction generation; most of it comes from a small group of very heavy users | Gupta et al. 2026 | A single dataset, English only |
| Loop | In a model trained on its own output, the rare disappears | Shumailov et al. 2024 | It does not say today's models have collapsed |
| Shared result | Model stories resemble each other more than human stories do | DK and Hatzel 2026; Russell et al. 2026; Doshi and Hauser 2024 | It does not separate how much each explanation contributes |
Training: why does narrative flatten?
In their study published at EMNLP 2026, Zehan Li, Yutong Zhu, Siyang Wu, Honglin Bao and James Evans compared four stages of a single open-weight model (OLMo 32B): the raw base model, supervised fine-tuning (SFT), preference training (DPO) and reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards (RLVR). Because the four stages share architecture, scale and pretraining, the difference between them can be attributed to the post-training stages. Each stage was given the opening of human stories and asked to continue it. The stories came from three places: a public story platform (StoryStar), prompt-guided stories (TMAS) and literary stories published in The New Yorker.
The post-training stages reduced variation on all three dimensions measured at sentence level: thematic motion, the prevalence of emotion in the text and linguistic diversity. The effect appeared in every story domain, but its size depended on the human text; the largest compression was in The New Yorker's literary stories. The continuations of the trained models converged regardless of source; according to the authors, this shows that the continuations remain largely insensitive to the narrative style of the source story. The authors named this loss "narrative flattening".
Interpretation: The training that makes a model coherent, readable and helpful may also be pulling it toward a single default writing regime. Because the study rests on a single model family, it is not known whether the effect is the same size in all models.
Demand: who wants the sameness?
Neel Gupta, Maria Antoniak and Melanie Walsh examined more than 500,000 anonymised, English-language chat-assistant conversations from a public dataset. More than a third of the conversations involved some kind of fiction generation: original stories, roleplay, fanfiction and erotica. Much of this output came from a small group of very heavy users. One of the patterns the authors describe is the "infinite story demander", who asks for and revises variations of similar narratives again and again over long periods. Users were drawn especially to familiar genre patterns, to repetition and to immediacy. The authors place AI fiction beside on-demand, personalised and repetitive cultural forms such as self-publishing and fanfiction.
Interpretation: Part of the sameness may not be a flaw of the model but the order itself. We reached a similar point in the article asking why we rewatch stories we already know: the familiar can carry value for the reader in its own right.
Loop: if the machine feeds on its own output
In Nature in 2024, Ilia Shumailov and colleagues examined what happens when model outputs are added indiscriminately to the training data of later models. They named the process they found "model collapse": as the generations go on, the tails of the original distribution, that is, the rare, disappear. In one of the experiments a chain that began with a text about medieval architecture turned, by the ninth generation, into an unrelated list of jackrabbits.
This study does not say that today's chat models have collapsed. It shows what could happen in a model trained indiscriminately on its own output. The detail that matters for literature is this: in this process, the first thing to disappear is not the average but the rare.
An old problem: pastiche, prosthetic memory and ghosts
AI did not invent the problem of sameness. The names cultural theory has given to this question are decades old.
- Pastiche (Jameson): In his work published in New Left Review in 1984 and expanded into a book in 1991, Fredric Jameson defines pastiche as parody's twin without the laughter: the imitation of a style, but without any critique or norm behind it. What Jameson calls the "nostalgia film" likewise reproduces not the past itself but stylised images of the past.
- Prosthetic memory (Landsberg): In 2004 Alison Landsberg gives this name to memories of a past a person did not live through, acquired through mass-cultural forms such as film and television. Landsberg does not read this only as a loss; she also sees it as a way of building empathy with other people's experience.
- Hauntology (Fisher): In 2014 Mark Fisher writes of a culture haunted by futures that never arrived: in music and film, past styles keep returning instead of something new.
A similar warning was made earlier about language models. In 2021 Emily Bender and colleagues used the metaphor of the "stochastic parrot" to draw attention to the fact that a language model can reproduce the form of language independently of meaning.
Interpretation: These concepts can be applied to language models as an analogy: a model, too, reproduces the styles of a cultural past it never lived. But this is an interpretation; Jameson, Landsberg and Fisher were not writing with language models in mind, and this application is not a tested claim. That is why this article proposes no new term. When established concepts already describe the same thing, a new name gives the reader nothing; it only breaks the chain of citation.
Where the doctrine looks: how emotion is delivered
The studies above measure sameness in plot, thematic motion and style. Objective Projection looks at another layer: how emotion reaches the reader. The doctrine calls the tendency of models to name emotion on the surface rather than encode it in physical detail delivery-mode drift, and defines it as a form of failure distinct from factual hallucination. We have discussed the ways models write emotion (naming it, stock bodily phrases, loading it onto objects) separately in the article on how AI writes emotion.
The narrative flattening study measures the prevalence of emotion in the text and finds that this variation falls as training goes on. But the study's abstract gives no information on whether this measure distinguishes between an emotion stated by name in the text and one shown through detail. The two questions are not the same: a text can name emotion rarely and show it strongly, or name it often and never show it.
The hypothesis the doctrine proposes is this: as training stages go on, models may name emotion more often and show it less often. This has not been tested yet. Testing it would require giving the same prompts to different training stages of the same model and having independent human annotators count the rate of emotion names and similes in the outputs. The doctrine's author cannot do this annotation himself. This design appears as a separate item in the Objective Projection research agenda and has not been run.
One prompt, two scenes
Prompt: A woman returns to her father's house after many years.
First, a scene close to the average. The author of this article wrote this example; it is not the output of any particular model. It only gathers the common markers of the average narrative:
When she opened the door a deep sorrow filled her. Everything was just like in her memories; it was as if time had stopped in this house. Her eyes filled with tears and for a moment she felt she had gone back to her childhood.
This scene has one emotion name (sorrow), two similes (just like in her memories, as if) and a stock phrase (time had stopped). Nothing is left for the reader to do; the scene says in advance what is to be felt.
With the same prompt, a scene that does not name the emotion:
The key went into the lock but would not turn. Nermin lifted the door with both hands and tried again; this time the bolt drew back. In the hallway her father's slippers stood facing the door, the heel of the right one pressed flat. In the kitchen the fridge motor started, then stopped. Nermin set her bag down beside the slippers, turning it to face the same way.
There is no emotion name in this scene. The reader draws her own inference from the flattened heel, from the fridge running in an empty house and from the bag being turned to face the same way. The heel can be read as an example of Micro Focus, the motor running in an empty house as an example of Atmosphere Contradiction.
Interpretation: The average scene is built from phrases that could be found in thousands of scenes. The details in the second scene belong to this house and this father. The specific detail may be one way against sameness; but this is not a tested solution, it is a writing suggestion.
What does this mean for a writer?
- Left to itself, the model goes to the average. According to DK and Hatzel's finding, negative prompting and temperature did not meaningfully change this. Describing the departure from the average through concrete detail rather than a general instruction may be an option (suggestion, untested).
- Taking the first idea from the model may draw stories closer together. Doshi and Hauser's experiment found that the stories of writers who took ideas resembled each other. Writing down your own idea before asking the model may be one way to limit this effect (suggestion, untested).
- If you ask for the same story again and again, part of the sameness may be coming from you. The data of Gupta and colleagues show that most fiction generation comes from a small group asking repeatedly for similar narratives.
- To see the emotion names and similes in your own text you can use the Scene Checker. The tool only counts and shows; it does not measure the quality of the text. The other tools are on the Objective Projection Tools page.
- When having a model write a scene, how you can ask it to convey emotion without naming it is covered in the prompting and fine-tuning guide.
This article is part of the series on AI and narrative. The question at the centre of the series is who the author is when AI writes the story. Whether readers can tell model stories from human stories is examined in a separate article; the finding there was that the difference lies not in style but in how the narrative is built.
What the doctrine cannot say here
- It cannot say whether a model story is good or bad. Sameness is not a measure of quality.
- It cannot separate how much of the sameness comes from each of the three explanations.
- It cannot say that models name emotion more often as training stages go on; this is a hypothesis.
- It cannot say that the specific detail removes sameness.
- It cannot say that applying the concepts of pastiche, prosthetic memory and hauntology to language models is correct; this is an interpretation.
Limitations
- Most of the studies reported rest on English texts; the study by Ma and colleagues is in Chinese. What happens in Turkish stories is not known.
- The studies by Li and colleagues and by Ma and colleagues were published at EMNLP 2026. The studies by DK and Hatzel, by Russell and colleagues and by Gupta and colleagues are arXiv preprints. The information on these five studies was taken from the abstracts on their publication pages; no figures were taken from the full texts.
- The author of this article wrote both example scenes; neither is the output of a model, and neither measures anything.
- The doctrine's concepts and the relations between them are listed in the knowledge graph of Levent Bulut, and the published records on the corpus page of Levent Bulut.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does AI keep writing the same story?
Three explanations may be working together. The training stages that turn a model into an assistant narrow the diversity of narrative; a small but very productive share of users asks for similar patterns again and again; and if model outputs enter retraining indiscriminately, the rare disappears. How much each contributes has not yet been separated.
Does raising the temperature or saying "don't use clichés" work?
In DK and Hatzel's 2026 study, negative prompting and temperature did not meaningfully reduce the similarity between model stories. Describing the departure through concrete detail rather than a general instruction may be an option; this, too, is not a tested method.
Does taking ideas from AI affect a writer's story?
In Doshi and Hauser's 2024 experiment, the stories of writers who took ideas from a model were judged individually more creative, but they resembled each other more. The authors described this as a social dilemma: individual gain comes together with a loss of collective diversity.
What is model collapse?
It is the process Shumailov and colleagues described in 2024: if model outputs are added indiscriminately to the training data of later models, the rare examples in the data disappear as the generations go on. The study does not say that today's models have collapsed; it shows what could happen under these conditions.
Is a new concept needed to describe this?
In this article's view, no. Jameson's pastiche, Landsberg's prosthetic memory and Fisher's concept of hauntology already name a similar situation for mass culture. The question Objective Projection adds is whether sameness also appears in how emotion is delivered; this question has not yet been tested.
References
- Bender, E. M., Gebru, T., McMillan-Major, A. and Shmitchell, S. (2021). On the Dangers of Stochastic Parrots: Can Language Models Be Too Big? Proceedings of FAccT '21, 610–623. https://doi.org/10.1145/3442188.3445922
- DK, T. and Hatzel, H. O. (2026). Do Large Language Models Always Tell The Same Stories? arXiv:2606.17350.
- Doshi, A. R. and Hauser, O. P. (2024). Generative AI enhances individual creativity but reduces the collective diversity of novel content. Science Advances, 10(28), eadn5290. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adn5290
- Fisher, M. (2014). Ghosts of My Life: Writings on Depression, Hauntology and Lost Futures. Zero Books.
- Gupta, N., Antoniak, M. and Walsh, M. (2026). AI Fiction in the Wild. arXiv:2606.22748.
- Jameson, F. (1984). Postmodernism, or, the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism. New Left Review, 146, 59–92. Expanded book: Duke University Press, 1991.
- Landsberg, A. (2004). Prosthetic Memory: The Transformation of American Remembrance in the Age of Mass Culture. Columbia University Press.
- Li, Z., Zhu, Y., Wu, S., Bao, H. and Evans, J. (2026). Narrative Flattening: How Post-Training Compresses Thematic, Affective, and Stylistic Variation in LLM Fiction. Proceedings of EMNLP 2026, 55222–55251. https://doi.org/10.18653/2026.emnlp-main.2433
- Ma, Y., Liu, J., Shi, K., He, H., Zhang, G., Zhao, Z., Hu, R. and Sun, M. (2026). Narrative Function Patterns in LLM-Generated Chinese Web Fiction: A Proppian Analysis. Proceedings of EMNLP 2026. https://doi.org/10.18653/2026.emnlp-main.1807
- Russell, J., Rajendhran, R., Pham, C. M., Iyyer, M. and Wieting, J. (2026). StoryScope: Investigating idiosyncrasies in AI fiction. arXiv:2604.03136.
- Shumailov, I., Shumaylov, Z., Zhao, Y., Papernot, N., Anderson, R. and Gal, Y. (2024). AI models collapse when trained on recursively generated data. Nature, 631, 755–759. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-07566-y
Citation
@misc{bulut2026samestory,
author = {Bulut, Levent},
title = {Why Does AI Keep Writing the Same Story? Three Explanations and an Old Problem},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://leventbulut.com/why-does-ai-keep-writing-the-same-story/}},
note = {leventbulut.com}
}